Answer: Only Sharp Eyes Catch The Menu Trick

Did you get it right?

This cafe menu puzzle gives three price clues for coffee, pie, and a muffin. The goal is to find the total price of one of each. The trick is that the prices do not come out to whole dollars.

Answer: Only Sharp Eyes Catch The Menu Trick

The Answer

The correct answer is: about $15.67.

Here is why

  1. Let coffee = C, pie = P, and muffin = M.
  2. 2C + P = 16, 2P + M = 14, and C + 2M = 17.
  3. Solving the three clues gives C = 53/9, P = 38/9, and M = 50/9.
  4. So C + P + M = 141/9 = 15.666…, which rounds to $15.67.

Why people miss it

Most people expect menu puzzles to use neat whole-dollar prices. This one uses a non-integer total, so quick guessing leads to the wrong answer.

What answer did you get before checking?